NYU's Independent Student Newspaper

Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

WSN Editorial Board

Gallatin sophomore Karlie Kloss came under fire recently for wearing yellowface in Vogue’s March issue. After the ensuing backlash on Twitter, Kloss posted an apology on her personal Twitter account. “These images appropriate a culture that is not my own,” the tweet said,”and I am truly sorry for participating in a shoot that was not culturally sensitive.”

While Kloss’s apology is certainly considerate and shows that she understands her mistake, a formal apology statement is also required from Vogue management. While Kloss should have used her position to influence the shoot, full responsibility for the incident falls on the magazine’s editorial staff as a whole.

In 2012, Kloss was involved in a similar incident when she was asked to wear a Native American headdress on the runway of the Victoria’s Secret fashion show. After receiving extensive criticism, Kloss tweeted an apology with her support for Victoria’s Secret’s decision to remove the outfit from the show broadcast. While the responsibility for this current yellowface mistake falls on Vogue, Kloss is clearly aware of the implications of cultural appropriation within the fashion world. In light of her success as a model and power within the industry, Kloss should decline offensive photoshoot proposals or influence the direction of the magazine.

Vogue is an influential fashion magazine, and it is well aware of its status. It should use this influence to show sensitivity when depicting other people’s cultures. The March issue was meant to celebrate diversity and inclusion, showing that Vogue is also conscious about the issues that people are talking about. The issue’s theme is also implied that the publication was aware that, if not careful, referencing another culture can easily lead to cultural appropriation. The blistering irony of appropriating Japanese culture in an issue celebrating diversity was apparently lost on Vogue’s editors.

While criticism of  Kloss is based on valid reasoning, she should not be facing more criticism than the company that orchestrated the shoot. Vogue put her in this shoot. By doing so, the magazine disregarded the implications of their actions and the precedent it would set. Cultural appropriation, especially in a large and mainstream setting, is unacceptable and Vogue’s lack of response on this matter speaks volumes about their overall corporate values.  

Email the WSN Editorial Board at opinion@nyunews.com.

Related Stories

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






1 Comment

One Response to “Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate”

  1. Man with the Axe on February 18th, 2017 8:20 pm

    What is wrong with dressing up as someone from another culture?

    Were the Beatles guilty of cultural appropriation when they sang “Michelle” partly in French? Are black women guilty of cultural appropriation when they straighten their hair? Am I guilty of cultural appropriation when I eat Chinese food? Is Eminem guilty of cultural appropriation when he sings hip-hop? Are Asian people guilty of cultural appropriation when they adopt American names?

    Why does anyone care that some other person likes his culture enough to want to participate in it?

Comments that are deemed spam or hate speech by the moderators will be deleted.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    NEWS

    Student Representation on Board of Trustees Wins in SSC Vote

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    Fashion Week

    Carmen Marc Valvo F/W 2017

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    Fashion Week

    Moncler Grenoble F/W 2017

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    Breaking News

    Blacked Out Bobst

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    Not Your Average Valentine’s Issue

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    NEWS

    Administration Freezes Class Tomorrow

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The Polarity Issue

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    2016 Election

    Protests and Attacks Cut Gavin McInnes’s Speech Short

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The New Year Issue

  • Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate

    2016 Election

    Protestors in Battery Park Respond to JFK Detainees

NYU's Independent Student Newspaper
Outrage Over Vogue Cultural Appropriation Is Appropriate