NYU's Independent Student Newspaper

Washington Square News

Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired

Lenore Tiefer, a
NYU School of Medicine psychiatry professor, was fired for not receiving her annual flu shot. At NYU Langone Medical Center, the influenza shot is important for patient safety.

via twitter.com

Lenore Tiefer, a NYU School of Medicine psychiatry professor, was fired for not receiving her annual flu shot. At NYU Langone Medical Center, the influenza shot is important for patient safety.

Htoo Min, Deputy News Editor

NYU School of Medicine psychiatry professor Leonore Tiefer was recently fired — for not receiving her annual flu shot.

In Tiefer’s termination letter, she was told that since the School of Medicine had not received evidence of her influenza vaccination, her faculty appointment would be terminated effective immediately.

Tiefer has her own private practice and is not exclusively involved with the university, so even though — according to Tiefer — doctors at Langone had the option to wear a mask instead of being immunized with the annual flu shot, she assumed that the policy did not apply to her since she is not a Langone employee.

“The mandatory flu vaccine policy at the NYUSOM is new this year — last year and before, there was an option to wear a mask,” Tiefer said. “Something changed this year — I don’t know what it is because the science around the vaccine hasn’t changed. [It’s] some new and excessively heavy-handed administrative initiative for some reason. I am a psychologist in private practice and have no patient contact at NYU so I did not regard the policy as applying to me.”

Tiefer said that the shot would have had little to no effect, so she made the decision to forgo it. To her dismay, many of her NYU faculty privileges were stripped without notice.

“I also know that the effectiveness of the flu shot is fairly low — it’s not a big-deal vaccine like polio or measles,” Tiefer said. “I was extremely surprised when my NYU email [address], library access and web page were suddenly and without warning taken down.”

Chief Epidemiologist at NYU Langone Michael Phillips said that the influenza shot is an important immunization and that it is a principle goal to be vaccinated as health care providers because patient safety is paramount in a medical setting. Phillips explained that such a policy should be enforced to ensure both the patient and the doctor are safe.

“Influenza is more than just a cold — it is a highly contagious disease that causes serious illness in close to 50,000 Americans each year — and in some cases, death,” Phillips said. “Certain individuals are particularly vulnerable to influenza, including patients — both those that are hospitalized as well as those in the ambulatory setting, particularly with compromised immune systems. As a healthcare provider, ensuring patient safety is our principal goal.”

Phillips also said that exemptions can be made if proper documentation is shown. He said that those who refuse to be immunized are to be educated about the importance of shots, and that anyone who still chooses to not abide by the standards is subject to disciplinary action.

“For employees seeking a non-medical or a non-religious personal exemption, we do everything possible to educate them about the safety and efficacy of the flu vaccine and its critical role in protecting them and protecting their patients,” Phillips said. “If an employee continues to refuse a flu shot, he or she can be subject to disciplinary action, including an unpaid leave of absence. We wish to be respectful of our employees — but must remain steadfast in our commitment to protect our patients.”

A version of this article appeared in the Monday, May 1 print edition.

Email Htoo Min at [email protected]

Related Stories

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.

Email This Story


10 Responses to “Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired”

  1. Linda Querel on May 1st, 2017 11:55 pm

    How is it possible that a vaccine with a low effeciency rate can protect anyone? The CDC admits this, one year 18%. A new study concluded that people who get the few shot are more susceptible to other flu strains. How does that protect anyone? There are some very serious side effects from the flu vaccines, consult the VAERS reports. Anyone vaccinated with a live virus shouldn’t be anywhere near a patient for 30 days. Do you check for this situation? Does it worry you that the flu vaccine comes with a large does of mercury, many times higher than the recommendation by the EPA. What compensation program do you offer when you force employees to be injected and they are left with severe injuries, like GB? This woman should sue for wrongful dismissal unless you can prove this vaccine is 100% safe and 85% effective.

  2. Emma on May 2nd, 2017 8:52 am

    There is recent evidence that people vaccinated for influenza may be 5 times more likely to become infected with other respiratory infections.

  3. Amy chapman on May 5th, 2017 9:56 am

    Fire her. She’s too stupid to teach. I’ve had the flu shot for the last twenty five years and not gotten the flu once. It works. It saves lives. It’s recommended by the CDC and required by every major hospital.

  4. Liam on May 6th, 2017 9:27 pm

    Parents wondering whether to send their college-bound daughters to NYU can begin by wondering about the level of sexism at work in a university that fires a female faculty member for choosing not to risk her health by placing her trust in controversial vaccine studies, but NOT to fire a male faculty member — an MD — who is so proud of his deceptive business practices he publishes them in a medical journal where his colleagues can then follow his easy step-by-step instructions on how to be wolves to their patients — i.e., the public. Institutionalized medical fraud doesn’t get any better than this. He’s a plastic surgeon, of course. Go to the following link and read the posts by bradymathew and samkrupke: http://messageboards.makemeheal.com/chin-jaw-implants/sliding-genioplasty-doctors-t164389.html?sid=dd9d0521540847b88353669c3772be61

  5. Traci on May 8th, 2017 1:24 pm

    Nice to see that there is still some critical thinking going on in our colleges. Check out VAERS for 2016. Flu shot wins for most damaging.

  6. Nora Villalobos on May 9th, 2017 10:28 am

    “The clinical results are not surprising to G. Russell Huffman, an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in shoulders at the University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine. ‘If you create this inflammatory response in the shoulder joint, it’s going to be manifested not with an hour of pain but with days, months, or possibly years of pain.'”

    “Shoulder injury petitions to the VICP have surged as annual flu vaccination has become routine….”

    — “Vaccines On Trial,” by Meredith Wadman; Science Vol. 356, 28 April 2017

  7. Anonymous on May 20th, 2017 12:07 pm

    More likely she was terminated with a pretext or phoney legal reason. Bad hospital.

  8. Seth on June 4th, 2017 1:03 pm

    Regarding May 6th post by “Liam.” Dr Barry Zide has tenure. Tenured faculty cannot be fired, and certainly not for expressing views or opinions they hold. We are a nation of free expression and free speech.

  9. David on June 18th, 2017 9:27 am

    To Seth of June 4th. Free speech and academic freedom are one thing. Promoting unethical (not to say criminal) conduct is another. Ask Michael Rectenwald if faculty can lose their jobs over the views they express and opinions they hold. Ask Ward Churchill. (I’m not comparing Rectenwald to Churchill.) Paul Campos has some interesting thoughts about what tenure ought and ought not to protect against: http://www.deseretnews.com/article/600109587/Tenure-shouldnt-protect-trash-spewing-professors.html

  10. David on June 18th, 2017 9:32 am

    P.S. Nor am I comparing Rectenwald to Zide.

Comments that are deemed spam or hate speech by the moderators will be deleted.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    NYU Student Sentenced to 45 Days in Jail for Albatross Murders

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    Gene Jarrett to Replace Gabi Starr as CAS Dean

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    SPS Changes Lead to Firing of 10 Faculty Members

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    Leonard N. Stern School of Business Commencement ‘17

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    Global Liberal Studies Commencement ‘17

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    School of Law Commencement ’17

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    Graduates of 185th Commencement Stand for Honor in the Face of Challenge

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    School of Medicine Commencement ‘17

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    College of Arts and Science Commencement ‘17

  • Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired


    Silver School of Social Work Commencement ’17

NYU's Independent Student Newspaper
Flu Shot-Free Professor Fired