NYU's Independent Student Newspaper

Washington Square News

Stop Using the Oxford Comma

Emma Rudd, Deputy Opinion Editor

On Monday, the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit decided that a Portland dairy company may have to pay up to $10 million in overtime, depending on the court’s reading of a state law. It all depends on an Oxford Comma — or lack thereof. In this instance, those who support the use of the Oxford Comma have won one round in the never-ending grammar debate. However, despite this, the Oxford Comma remains an unnecessary embellishment in the writing process — only required when the original message of the text is already ambiguous.

Professional and notable publications like The New York Times and The Economist don’t use the Oxford Comma and still maintain a reputable standing. If they can produce a fluid and precise collection of work without the Oxford Comma, then why can’t everyone else? Oxford Comma supporters frequently cite the need for clarification by using obscure examples, such as if one were to write “I love my parents, Beyoncé and Chance the Rapper” then the reader will assume that the author’s parents are Beyoncé and Chance the Rapper. Yet these few random cases are the only instances where Oxford Commas would matter, and even then, the entirety of the piece should clarify the meaning of the sentence in question.

It is also frequently argued by supporters that the Oxford Comma is necessary for formal writing —  like in novels or poetry — but it still remains just as unnecessary. The silent punctuation mark does nothing but add an extra character to a piece. If the integrity of the sentence is so completely changed by the addition or exclusion of a simple comma, then a quick rewording is the best option. If the formality of the piece hinges on a tiny black mark, then maybe the whole work should be reconsidered.

Although the lack of an Oxford Comma has prompted a possible $10 million loss for the Portland dairy company Oakhurst Dairy, this case is an anomaly. If the state law on overtime work was reworded more precisely, the need for the Oxford Comma would be irrelevant. While many supporters will cite this incident as a need for Oxford Comma inclusion, the opposition has already gained ground with the dismissal of the comma in the AP Stylebook and acknowledgment of the comma’s unimportance by the popular band, Vampire Weekend. It’s time to dispose of the meaningless comma for good and simply produce more fluid and unambiguous writing instead.

Opinions expressed on the editorial pages are not necessarily those of WSN, and our publication of opinions is not an endorsement of them. A version of this article appeared in the Monday, March 20 print edition. 

Email Emma Rudd at [email protected]

Related Stories

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






3 Comments

3 Responses to “Stop Using the Oxford Comma”

  1. Sean Spencer on March 22nd, 2017 11:56 am

    Kind of ridiculous to be against the Oxford comma. Is that extra tick just took much work for you?

  2. Jack Richards on March 23rd, 2017 1:05 am

    I agree that in instances such as the current legal battle there is an opportunity to use less ambiguous language, but for a list of three or more items, I agree with Sean’s comment that the reason to get rid of it shouldn’t be a distaste for the physical comma. In your article you even state that there are “instances where Oxford commas would matter,” and you do not give an example of instances where a sentence is made better, and more clear, by not having it. So even if there are few instances where having it is better, isn’t it worth having?

  3. Man with the Axe on March 25th, 2017 12:09 am

    “I had sex last night with my girlfriend, a wonderful woman and my best friend. “

Comments that are deemed spam or hate speech by the moderators will be deleted.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




 

Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    The Obsoleteness of Textbooks

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    NYU SJP’s Rally Can Help Spread Safety

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Commencement Tickets Not Yours to Sell

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Problematic Portrayal of Female Friendship in ‘Girls’

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Weekend on the Square Protests Embarrassed NYU

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Venezuela: The Media’s Victim

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    NYU Is Lacking Diversity Among Faculty and Administration

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Residential Staff Should Be Trained for Opioid Overdose Prevention

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Staff Rants April 19-25

  • Stop Using the Oxford Comma

    OPINION

    Protests Show a More Accurate NYU

NYU's Independent Student Newspaper
Stop Using the Oxford Comma