NYU's Independent Student Newspaper

Washington Square News

The Oxford Comma Is a Must

Andrew Heying, Deputy Opinion Editor

Of all the wondrous and beautiful grammatical conventions, perhaps the most controversial is the Oxford Comma. Over the years, this contentious convention has incited furious debate amongst grammar lovers and even inspired a popular song by Vampire Weekend. Recently, Maine’s choice to forgo using the Oxford Comma has sparked a lawsuit that could end up costing the state $10 million, proving the absolute necessity of this magnificent convention.

The Oxford Comma may seem trivial, but it can drastically change the meaning of a sentence. Many see this debate as a pretentious one, but the Oxford Comma is vital, even in everyday writing. For example, if someone says, “I love my parents, Beyoncé, and Chance the Rapper,” this makes perfect sense. However, if someone removes the Oxford Comma, the sentence becomes quite different in saying, “I love my parents, Beyoncé and Chance the Rapper.” Some argue that it should be up to the reader to decode this sentence, but this is ridiculous. If someone does not keep up with pop culture, they may see nothing wrong with the idea of Beyoncé and Chance the Rapper having a child together. Thus the second sentence could leave them extremely misinformed, which is the antithesis of quality writing.

The Oxford Comma is even more important in formal writing. Even though the AP Stylebook — which most major publications follow — rules against the Oxford Comma, it is unwise to do so. For example, the sentence, “In his free time, President Donald Trump enjoys eating, his wife, and his children,” makes perfect sense. However, if the Oxford cCmma is removed, the sentence becomes quite different in reading, “In his free time, President Donald Trump enjoys eating, his wife and his children.” Despite grievances some may have with the President, no one is suggesting he is a cannibal. However, without the Oxford Comma, the aforementioned sentence suggests just that.

The Oxford Comma is a magnificent piece of grammar that is vital to the fluidity of the English language. The comma can drastically alter sentences, causing confusion and even legal disputes. In a world where words have considerable power, we must ensure clarity. If not, it is only a matter of time until something drastic happens because someone was confused in the absence of the outstanding Oxford Comma.

Opinions expressed on the editorial pages are not necessarily those of WSN, and our publication of opinions is not an endorsement of them. A version of this article appeared in the Monday, March 20 print edition. 

Email Andrew Heying at [email protected]

Related Stories

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






1 Comment

One Response to “The Oxford Comma Is a Must”

  1. Ian on March 22nd, 2017 12:48 pm

    Your example, as you have it written, does not function well as an argument in favor of the Oxford Comma, rather as a counter argument. The comma present in the sentence “Trump enjoys eating, his wife and his children” excludes the possibility of being understood as direct objects of the verb . In this case the exclusion of the OC has nothing to do with how one reads the sentence, and in the sentence containing the OC the extra comma is certainly gratuitous. I am not necessarily against the OC, it has its place in certain situations, but it should be noted that this example does not support your argument.

Comments that are deemed spam or hate speech by the moderators will be deleted.

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Right
Navigate Left
  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    Up-and-Comers 2017

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The Innovation Issue

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The Culture Shock Issue

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The Health Issue

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    Housing

    The 2017 Housing Guide

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    SPECIAL EDITIONS

    The Fashion Week Issue

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    NEWS

    Student Representation on Board of Trustees Wins in SSC Vote

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    Fashion Week

    Carmen Marc Valvo F/W 2017

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    Fashion Week

    Moncler Grenoble F/W 2017

  • The Oxford Comma Is a Must

    Breaking News

    Blacked Out Bobst

NYU's Independent Student Newspaper
The Oxford Comma Is a Must